FlixChatter Review: YESTERDAY (2019)

I love The Beatles. In fact, my record collection (to quote Twin Cities label legend Peter Jesperson) begins with The Beatles and then goes from A-Z. During a company outing I struck up the subject by asking my coworkers: “You guys like The Beatles?” Their answer: “Who doesn’t like The Beatles?” And indeed, with Danny Boyle’s latest film, this assumption is rendered universal which is one of the key factors in making the premise of “Yesterday” work its magic.

Himesh Patel plays Jack Malik, a fledgling singer-songwriter, who despite his dedication and commitment to his trade just doesn’t seem to have the ‘thing’ to make it in the music industry. Gig after gig, from coffee house to festival circuit, no one seems to want to give his songs a listen. All except for one: local schoolteacher Elle (Lily James), his manager and childhood friend. She believes in his songs and most significantly, in him. After a failed gig at a music festival, Jack decides to hang it up. While riding home on his bike, suddenly the world changes. Inexplicably, in this world The Beatles never existed. No one remembers them, except for Malik of course. Armed with these songs, he is now in quite a predicament – or opportunity: What to do? A catalog full of Lennon-McCartney classics to be owned for the taking; to share them to the world or to pass them off as his own?

Patel is excellent as Malik, portraying him with sincerity and humor. Patel is also convincing as a musician, playing and singing with his own voice which is quite good given the awesome repertoire he’s been given. Lily James is simply radiant as Elle and acts as a great foil to Malik once his Hero’s Journey takes an uncontrollable turn. She is the down-to-earth element in his skyward trajectory to fame and fortune. But will he realize it in time before it’s too late?

The other stars in Yesterday are obviously the songs of Lennon-McCartney. The film assumes that we are familiar with them enough to get the in-jokes and album references. Being a Beatles fan myself, they are overly obvious and simplistic but quite satisfying. Admittedly, it’s a fantasy that friends and I have imagined in our younger years as we obsessed about The Beatles and endlessly played them on our aging turntables.

It’s a simple story, a fantasy/romantic comedy that asks us to escape to another dimension where The Beatles never existed. But I can’t help but think how the world would be so much different without The Beatles. Steve Jobs named his company Apple after the group’s record label. Would Ed Sheeran, who has a bit role playing himself, even exist in such a world? Part of the Rolling Stones success was its friendly rivalry with the fab four, yet they exist in this world as if it didn’t matter. Would the masses really have taken to the songs so quickly in such an environment, even with the help of social media technologies like YouTube and twitter? In my view, The Beatles were that influential to the state of contemporary culture since the 60s. Musicologists would probably correct me for these statement but the bottom line is that Yesterday asks us not to think too hard about those details but just to climb on board and enjoy the ride.

Filled with humor, amusing pop culture references, great songs and strong performances from the two leads, Yesterday is highly entertaining as long as we don’t think about it to too much. And by the way, part of The Beatles charm was their happy-go-lucky and not-so-serious nature (at least in the beginning). Wouldn’t it be nice to live in the surreal, joyous world that is portrayed by Richard Lester’s A Hard Day’s Night? With Yesterday, Danny Boyle gives us 2 hours to forget the world’s troubles and ask ourselves “What if?”


So did you get to see YESTERDAY? Let us know what you think!

13 thoughts on “FlixChatter Review: YESTERDAY (2019)

    1. rockerdad

      Haha the Ed Sheeran comment cracked me up! Not really familiar with his work but keep seeing him pop up here there…

  1. Nice review Vince, can’t say I’m a fan of The Beatles but have heard some of their famous songs back when I was younger. This films sounds interesting and I’m a fan of Boyle’s work, still bummed that he didn’t get to make a James Bond film. I’ll probably give this one a watch when it hits Netflix or Amazon Prime.

    1. rockerdad

      Yeah, in your case it might be a hard sell. It’s missing some of that hard edge that is in most of Boyle’s work.

  2. Pingback: Member Reviews: “Yesterday” – Online Association of Female Film Critics

  3. Awesome review as always Vince! I REALLY wanna see this one. I’m not a huge fan of The Beatles but I think I’d still enjoy this. I do love Lily James and I read some reviews that said her character was only there to serve Jack’s story, so that’s a bummer. I also read a rather disheartening interview w/ Danny Boyle where he said he felt ‘unfit’ to make films about female protagonists, hence all his movies are told from the male perspectives. Heh, he could collaborate with a female screenwriter or something, but sounds like he’d rather stay in his ‘comfort zone’ and let other filmmakers make films about women. Sorry that just makes me sad and kinda not want to support this filmmaker, y’know.

    1. rockerdad

      Yeah I have to agree about Lily being mostly a wallflower in this one. I have not heard that interview but that is very disheartening indeed.

  4. Pingback: JUNE Viewing Recap: INDIAN SUMMERS, Netflix’s Murder Mystery, Unlocked, etc. – FlixChatter Film Blog

  5. Pingback: Nostalgia with Yesterday – What J Has to Say

Join the conversation by leaving a comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s