Weekend Roundup: Musings on A Room with a View

It’s Monday again! Did you all have a nice weekend? Well, it’s a nice one weather-wise here in the Twin Cities, in fact, it could very well be one of the best Halloween weather ever. We usually get snow or unusually chilly temps, but yesterday there wasn’t a cloud in the gorgeous blue sky and it was warm enough to forgo your jacket!

Friday was Girls Movie Night for October, where my girlfriends and I take turn hosting dinner and a movie. A Room with a View had been on our to-watch list for some time, but due to a couple of snafus on my part, we haven’t been able to get the movie until now. It’s a Merchant-Ivory period drama starring a then 19-year-old Helena Bonham Carter set in Edwardian England at the turn of the 20th century. I suggested this movie after reading all the accolades this movie got (winning 3 Oscars, and a slew of other awards), and the story of illicit romance appeals to me.

The movie opens with a gorgeous view of Florence where Lucy Honeychurch (Bonham Carter) and her chaperon Charlotte Bartlett (Maggie Smith) are vacationing. Unfortunately, they didn’t get the view from the room they were promised to get, and they complain about it over dinner (I suppose I’d be too given the view is of the Ponte Vecchio bridge over Arno river!). Upon learning about the situation, fellow guests Mr. Emerson and his son George gladly give up their room-with-a-view to Lucy and Charlotte. Before long, sparks fly between George and Lucy, and George makes sure Lucy knows it. But Charlotte reminds Lucy that George isn’t the perfect suitor, as the Emersons aren’t as socially acceptable (basically for being too ‘open’ for such a stifled society), and so she must let her go and marry someone her family would approve. To complicate matters, the Emersons end up becoming their neighbors and not only disrupts her nuptial plans but also challenge her way of thinking, as well as those closest to her.

Perhaps I should give this movie another go, but upon initial viewing, it didn’t wow me as much as I thought it would. I like the premise of the movie, but I thought the movie is kind of all over the place and boring at times. I actually dozed off the last 15 minutes of the movie, I did wake up just before the closing credits when George & Lucy sit by the window exactly like in the movie poster. It’s quite obvious the plot is predictable, but I don’t mind that so much if I can just get into characters. Aside from their first unexpected but passionate kiss in the fields, I never quite get into the main love story. The baby-faced Bonham Carter captured the sweet innocence of her character, yet she just wasn’t captivating enough for me to root for her. But the worst part is Julian Sands’ stilted performance, which pretty much drew jeers from my girlfriends for his unconvincing delivery. He just wasn’t compelling enough in the ‘romeo’ role, in fact, there’s a lack of emotion from the romance the entire plot is built on, which is a pity as it would’ve been a far more engaging movie. There are strong performances from Maggie Smith and Judi Dench, but the scene stealer here is the unrecognizable Daniel Day-Lewis as Cecil, Lucy’s bookish and pretentious fiance. His character is a stark contrast to the free-spirited, fun-loving George, and we’re supposed to dislike him, but his amusing portrayal truly is one of the highlights of the movie. No wonder Daniel’s career is light years ahead of the actor in the lead role.

Photo courtesy of Pixelcrave.net

Oh, one thing I didn’t quite expect from this period drama is the scene of male frontal nudity in the skinny dipping scene. I’m not talking about a brief glimpse but an extensive scene of the three male characters being shown clowning around freely in and out of water, there’s even a chase scene that lead to the women discovering George and Lucy’s brother Freddy in their birthday suit. I suppose it’s meant to show the stark contrast between the openness of the modern sensibilities and the repressed culture of the day, which seems to suggest that modesty equals ‘uptight.’ Well, call us old fashioned but we we were as taken aback as the female characters in the movie and we certainly won’t be comfortable running into guys skinny dipping in real life. The scene itself is pretty hilarious, it wasn’t scandalous or obscene, but it did take us away from the movie for a little bit.

Overall, it’s a decent movie and I’m glad I watched it, but I can’t say I love it. It’s a gorgeous movie for sure, what with the Florentine art and architecture, the melodious Beethoven music and the picturesque scenes of Italy and English countryside, if only the romance is equally bewitching. If anything though, it made me want to go back to Firenze pronto!


Anybody has seen this film? Well, what did you think?

13 thoughts on “Weekend Roundup: Musings on A Room with a View

    1. Yeah, I’m surprised how much people adore this movie though… calling it a masterpiece and all. Well, it’s not horrible but a masterpiece? I don’t think so. DDL is amazing though, I asked my girlfriends to guess who he was because all of them said he looked familiar… and only one recognized him! Love him!

  1. PrairieGirl

    Would love to see it if only for the England and Italy locations. Is it worth it for that? I would venture yes, since you were ready to go right back to Firenze!

    1. Well, I’d say the movie is worth a watch, I was curious about it as it’s such a beloved piece that won a lot of awards. The scenery is indeed beautiful, there is a pretty brutal scene towards the beginning at Piazza della Signoria though but for the most part it’s just lovely. I wish my hotel had the same view when we were in Florence, my window overlooked an alley with only a slight glimpse of the Duomo 😦

  2. Pingback: просмотр фильма гладиатор « Эхо блогосферы

  3. this is a movie for a Sunday evening 🙂 It was nice, but nothing special, but I do love two good friends Maggie Smith and Judi Dench.
    If you ask me, the film I enjoyed the most from Helena Bonham Carter were some of her early ones – the amazing and thrilling and ultra romantic flick A HAZARD OF HEARTS from 1987, which is very dramatic and sexy at the same time, and perfect for the ladies who love a bit of dashing romance.

    Another one is LADY JANE, a great film about one of my favourite historical characters, the unfortunate lady Jane.

    1. Yeah, the interaction between the two dames are great to watch, I love how gossip-y they are just women are in real life 🙂 I haven’t seen either one of those movies, but I don’t mind a bit of dashing romance… I like movies about the royal family too, so I’m intrigued by Lady Jane… doesn’t hurt that it’s got Cary Elwess, too 😉

      1. ah, Flixy darling, Cary is the best part of LADY JANE (she was a very interesting character, being a queen for just a day or two or something like that), and I know you would fall in love with the main actor in A HAZARD OF HEART too if you watch it, actually I think your knees will shake a bit 🙂 🙂

        1. Oooh ok then, you’ve convinced me! He’s so dashing and funny in Princess Bride and Robin Hood Men in Tights… he even make for a smarmy villain in Twister.

          Who’s the main actor in A Hazard of Hearts… it’s a made-for-tv movie right? Are you talking about Christopher Plummer??

          1. no, no, it’s not Plummer off course 🙂 This is some actor I’ve never seen before nor after that film, but he and Helena had such an amazing chemistry in that film and plus it helps that he is a very dashing gentleman when put in a 19th century suit 🙂

                1. Ooooh yes, he is dashing indeed. Lord Vulcan actually sounds like something out of Flash Gordon but no matter, who cares what his name is if he looks like THAT 😀

                  Thanks for sending the link Dez!

Leave a Reply to bananaoilmovies Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s