Directed by: Josh Ruben
Starring: Olivia Holt, Mason Gooding, Michaela Watkins, Jordana Brewster, Devon Sawa
Hollywood tends to take advantage of the seasons from a marketing standpoint and Valentine’s Day is no exception. Heart Eyes, interestingly tries to deliver on that V-Day niche, falling under the classification of Romantic Comedy/Slasher/Horror flick. Sounds like the ultimate date movie right?
The premise: In recent years, Seattle has experienced a slew of grisly murders of romantic couples by a masked serial killer nicknamed Heart Eyes, whose goggles are shaped like hearts. Meanwhile, Ally (Olivia Holt), an advertising creative is struggling with her latest Valentine’s Day campaign. Her boss (Michaela Watkins), in trying to salvage the campaign, hires young consultant Jay (Mason Gooding) to team up with Ally. While out at dinner to ‘talk shop’, they are mistaken by Heart Eyes as a couple and become the killer’s next target. Mayhem ensues. Romance and laughs, maybe a little but not much.
Ally is strategically cute, and Jay is appropriately buff but there’s not much chemistry there. Some laughs include a bedroom toy device and a reference to Jordana Brewster’s Fast and Furious franchise but not much else. For fans of creative gore, it’s a little more worthwhile but it’s not enough to carry the whole film. Now, whether it’s a fitting date movie would depend on the demographic it’s aimed at. In this case, middle school to high school sounds about right, even with its R rating (that never stopped a clever teen from seeing this in some form).
Heart Eyes is pretty light fare, with some gore to satisfy horror fans. Though it’s predictable to the core, it never once takes itself too seriously – and that is its best feature. Your date might approve this as long as you pay his/her admission price. However, with the overpriced nature of the concession stands, something like Soderberg’s Presence (2025) might be a better option.

So have you seen HEART EYES? Well, what do you think?
…




Oh… oh well. NEXT!
haha yep.
Sounds like a movie that I would’ve enjoyed back in grade school or high school. Lol! I did see a trailer of this one a while back, it’s not something I seek out anymore. Now that I’m older, I prefer a horror film with some substance. I’ll give Soderberg’s Presence a watch when it hits streaming.
yeah that one is interesting for sure. I saw it in a mostly empty theater which made it more creepy.
Oh no! Can we expect a review from Ruth for a second opinion?
probably not 😆
Hi Luka, I’m afraid I don’t do horror. I just don’t have the stomach for blood and gore.
Aww, that’s too bad this isn’t better, because the “heart eyes” concept is pretty hilarious.
Agree. I took my teenage son who loves horror flicks. He likened it to a made for tv movie on the CW with gore.
Haha I’m not sure Ruth would be willing to do that…
Pingback: FlixChatter Review: LOVE HURTS (2025) – Ke Huy Quan is lovable as ever, but this not-so-sweet Valentine thriller makes me wince – FLIXCHATTER FILM BLOG
Pingback: The Minnesota Movie Digest: Issue No. 127 – The Minnesota Film Critics Association
LOL! Probably won’t watch this.
In another time of my life, this sounds like a fab Drive-In movie.
I sure miss the Drive-In!
Thanks Ruth!